Pudgies` Pizza in Wellsboro

Nobody in this place that works here washes their hands

wont answer the phone

Quality pizza!

Our order was completely butchered today. We got there and they missed an entire order of wings. So we had to wait. Our pizza was half pep and have cheese when we ordered all pep. We ordered honey BBQ for one of the wings and got regular bbq. We also ordered extra sauce and barely had sauce at all! The computers were down. Understandable that it's difficult but the customer service was terrible as well. In fact my review would have been better considering their situation, but while we were there the guy who waited on us was throwing attitude left and right and answering the phone, putting people on hold and never going back or answering and hanging up. This made us realize that he did that to us when we called we had to call 4 times!! Terrible experience.

Good food good prices an easy place to find

Is good food but the pizza sauce is a bit sour.

Good food and fast. Reasonable prices.

Good food and service. Love that they deliver

Get the Hawaiian pizza!

Cheaper than foxes. Tons of beer to choose from. Staff are friendly and place is kept very clean.

They have a gluten-free pizza that's not half bad. Tastes like a thin/crispy. A decent choice for people with gluten allergies.

Not my first choice for pizza but their wings are good. Their carry out beer selection is great and they often carry items that can't be found elsewhere in the area.

Called before hand for party having at my sister and was stopping to pick it up on our way though. Told it be ready by 2:20 pm I got there late by like 30 minutes but anyway got there and it wasn't even ready . they claimed it got lost but they weren't even busy. While I waited another customer came in rang 4 the bell a couple different times the two guys looked at him but never waited on him, so guy left after telling me he only wanted a slice of pizza.

I love Pudgies!

My top location for delicious pizza. the food was amazing. i'll return friends next time. the bill was decent.

After looking on line to order a pick up, the menu is useless. Order 3 different personal calzones, the boxes weren't marked as to what kind...the best part...got 3...but only 2 different kinds

They have the best pizza and the best wings.

Great location for delicious pizza. You will not be disappointed in the menu and service. Looking forward to coming back with my coworkers. The bill was average for the menu. This place has good reviews for a reason.

The food is okay,but rarely gets our orders correct.

Beer cooler

Ask for extra blue cheese to go with wings and they gave me 2 containers of ranch dresding

A local favorite. Pizza is delicious and fresh. The sheet pizza is huge!

Their burgers are already precooked before you order them.The wings had a funny taste. I ordered six and only ate two of them.They had either freezer burn or they were thawed and refrozen.But the staff was nice.Sorry, won't be back.

Can be greasy. Seem very understaffed.

Awesome making me a pudgie burger

Pudgies is always good, and the selection of beers and ales is impressive. Since they downsized and focus on mainly their pizzas, the quality has actually improved.

Not the original pizza recipe but still good pizza. Buy 1 get one slices is insanely awesome! Good selection of 6 packs to go too. Subway is in same building if other people aren't feeling like pizza.

Great food, awesome beer cave decent prices.

Ordered 2 sheets and 2 doz wings for Superbowl for a 5pm pickup. Was done, on time, and was delicious!

Three years ago, I had the best buffalo chicken wing pizza I had ever had from the Wellsboro, Pa Pudgies. Recently my experience was the complete opposite. They used different chicken that taste and smells like it has been sitting in the fridge for two weeks. I do not think I will be getting pizza from this location ever again.

Best chain pizza in Willpo!

They burn the pizza and then have to remake how do you burn a pizza much better pizza at pudgies in mansfield don't waste your time here how it stays in business beats me besides offering beer

Louzy food poisoningin every time we go there

I've never been here. I guess driving by counts as a visit. It was a comfortable visit sitting in my car driving by. Clearly a 2 star drive by

Loved the pizza! Inexpensive also!

One of my preferred places for Pizza. visited on fri i believe. the prices are well within reason for the quality.

This is a pretty good pizza and wing place. I ordered pizza and wings to go one night. They also have a walk in cooler with a nice craft beer selection.

Pizza... so tasty. the service was very kind and attentive. the place has a great atmosphere.

Pizza at this spot - yummy. The service here is better than most. This place has a great feel to it.

Good food

They changed their wings. They switched to a pre-cooked wing to save money and increase their margins. The new wings are gross, small and fleshy, not crispy. 11/20 update: just learned that their parent company threatened to fire employees for telling customers the food changed...did they think no one would notice?